My Voyage to Italy
aka Il Mio Viaggio in Italia

Martin Scorsese

Documentary. USA/Italy, 2001. Rated PG-13. 243 minutes.

Featuring: Martin Scorsese
Editor: Thelma Schoonmaker
Cinematographers: Phil Abraham, William Rexer
Producers: Giorgio Armani, Barbara De Fina, Guiliana Del Punta, Bruno Restuccia
Director: Martin Scorsese


Grade: A- Review by Jeff Vorndam

R egardless of what happens with Gangs of New York, Martin Scorsese will have at least one movie that could end up on my top ten list at year's end. My Voyage to Italy conveys an infectious enthusiasm for cinema and shines a light on several groundbreaking films that influenced not only Scorsese, but also filmmakers and cineastes worldwide. It's similar to his previous Personal Journey through American Cinema, but doesn't tackle as broad a canvas. Where the earlier cinematic survey touched on scores of films and filmmakers, Voyage burrows more deeply into the works of the five major post-WWII Italian directors: Roberto Rossellini, Vittorio De Sica, Luchino Visconti, Michelangelo Antonioni, and Federico Fellini.

Roughly 45 minutes are devoted to each director, and about five films apiece are examined. Scorsese begins with the seminal neo-realist films of the mid-40s and finishes with the decidedly unrealistic 8 , from 1963. Antonioni's L'Avventura(It's rumored that Scorsese plans a follow-up documentary covering Italian cinema post-1963.)

In a brief introduction, Scorsese explains the formative effect these movies had on him as a child. Growing up in Little Italy, he encountered many of these movies for the first time on television, dubbed in English. For him, they were a link to his cultural heritage, and his immigrant family took the scenes of war-torn Rome in Rossellini's Open City as reports from back home--the news of the day. These crude-looking imports stood in marked contrast to the polished Hollywood product Scorsese saw on the big screen. They seemed from another world entirely, a world without happy endings, and one that examined serious issues of poverty, morality, and religion. It's the two sides of cinema, one sensational and slick, the other hard-hitting and realistic, that Scorsese later melded into his own style.

Watching the film, I could see which scenes and films were big influences on Scorsese, not just in terms of style but philosophy as well. When they showed the introduction of the characters in Fellini's I Vitelloni, it looked almost exactly like something from Mean Streets or Goodfellas. The camera glides from one young hoodlum to the next, as the voice-over identifies each character. De Sica's The Bicycle ThiefThe conveyance of compassion for the characters in Rossellini's Flowers of St. Francis reminded me of Bringing out the Dead. Nicolas Cage's description of his vocation as a "grief mop" bore a resemblance to St. Francis' work assisting the unfortunate. And now I know what Pauline Kael meant when she referred to the "Antonioni pirouette" in Taxi Driver--a camera that shuns its human subject to contemplate a building, or a hallway.

It's a fair bet that most people will not have seen many of these films. A handful of them aren't even available on video. Among the titles I found especially interesting, but hadn't seen yet: Paisan, Voyage to Italy, La Terra Trema, Senso, I Vitelloni, and L' Eclisse. Of the films I had seen, what struck me most was that I need to see these films restored and on the big screen. The Bicycle Thief, in particular, packed a much stronger punch in the bits that were shown versus my mild enthusiasm for it on video. Although well served by its Criterion DVD, 8 is something else entirely when seen with a large picture and good sound--I've never seen such exquisite white-on-white photography, and the way the sound cuts out in Guido's dream sequence at the fountain sent pleasure-chills down my spine. Mere clips of De Sica's Umberto D sent just about everyone around me into tears (okay, I may have let loose a drop or two). Unfortunately, torn from context, it seems much more crassly manipulative than it is.

Scorsese has a penchant for locating the key sequences in each film. His voice-over is informative, but he has the sense to know when to withhold it, and let the original picture do the talking. Those who wish to encounter these films without spoilers should not see this movie though. Nearly every scene is pivotal. However, I can attest from having seen A Personal Journey Through American Cinema that there's a thrill in seeing these climactic scenes presented in context. It's like when you listen to an album for the first time and your favorite single comes up. So this is where it belongs. Think of My Voyage to Italy as a compilation of hit singles from the Italian masters. You walk out of this movie having seen not just one great film, but many.

My Voyage to Italy will premiere on Turner Classic Movies Friday, June 7, 8:00PM (ET).

Review © May 2002 by AboutFilm.Com and the author.

  Comment on this review on the boards  

  Official site
  IMDB page
  MRQE page
  Rotten Tomatoes page