The Top 25 Films of the 1990s
page 2

#9  Babe (1995)

Starring James Cromwell, Magda Szubanski, and the voices of Christine Cavanaugh, Miriam Margolyes, Danny Mann, and Hugo Weaving.
Written by George Miller and Chris Noonan based on The Sheep-Pig, by Dick King-Smith.
Directed by Chris Noonan.

The Grades
Alison
A-
Carlo
A 
Dana
Jeff
A-
Jen
A+
Kris
-

Roscoe Lee Browne puts it best in his narration, "This is a tale of an unprejudiced heart, and how it changed our valley forever." The valley itself is an enchanting place, in no easily identifiable geographic location or era. The farm, run by the lanky, stoic Arthur Hoggett (Cromwell) and his portly, cheerful wife (Szubanski), has a strict hierarchy and order. Babe, a talking pig, upsets the status quo when he demonstrates his unwillingness to accept his destiny–as the Christmas ham–with an uncanny ability to herd sheep alongside the dogs. Hoggett, in his own quiet way, rebelliously challenges convention by not only recognizing Babe's talent, but nourishing it.

This is a superbly crafted film, a magical blend of technology and heart. The art direction, cinematography, acting, editing, special effects, writing, and musical score swirl together to form a delightful concoction. One of the most pleasant surprises of the decade, Babe deserved every ounce of its praise, including its Oscar nomination. It has deservedly become an enduring, beloved favorite of children and adults alike.  –Jen

Academy Awards™
Best Visual Effects.
Nominations: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Supporting Actor (Cromwell), Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Film Editing, Best Art Direction/Set Decoration.

Other Major Awards
Broadcast Film Critics Association: Best Family Film.
Golden Globes: Best Picture-Comedy/Musical.
London Critics Circle: Film of the Year, Newcomer of the Year (Noonan).
National Society of Film Critics: Best Film.
New York Film Critics Circle: Best New Director.

Back to the Top 100.

#10  Unforgiven (1992)

Starring Clint Eastwood, Morgan Freeman, Gene Hackman, Richard Harris, Jaimz Woolvett, Saul Rubinek, and Frances Fisher.
Written by David Webb Peoples.
Directed by Clint Eastwood.

The Grades
Alison
A-
Carlo
A 
Dana
Jeff
A 
Jen
A+
Kris
B+

With Unforgiven, Clint Eastwood has managed to not only break Western genre bounds, but also the bounds of the anti-Western, a genre he helped create with Italian director Sergio Leone. William Munny is a man with a name–and a reputation to match. There is no mystery to this man as he rides into the western town of Big Whisky with clear intentions–to kill two men in exchange for money.

The title of the film is quite apt. Eastwood paints the Old West in a deservedly unforgiving light. He forgoes the majestic musical scores that always accompany panoramic western vistas. His shoot-outs are slow, messy, and agonizing. Nobody gets what they deserve.

Unforgiven completely shatters Western mythology, stripping it of all the glamour, all the glory, and all the romance. The whores don't have hearts of gold. The sheriff keeps the peace through brutality and intimidation. And the gunfighting protagonist is a mean, vicious murderer.

With Unforgiven, Eastwood delivers his message loud and clear; that everything we've ever seen before about the Old West is bullshit. Even his own movies.  –Jen

Academy Awards™
Best Picture, Best Director, Best Supporting Actor (Hackman), Best Film Editing.
Nominations: Best Actor (Eastwood), Best Original Screenplay, Best Cinematography, Best Art Direction/Set Decoration, Best Sound.

Other Major Awards
British Academy Awards: Best Supporting Actor (Hackman).
Directors Guild of America: Outstanding Directorial Achievement.
Golden Globes: Best Director, Best Supporting Actor (Hackman).
Los Angeles Film Critics Association: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor (Eastwood), Best Supporting Actor (Hackman), Best Screenplay.
National Society of Film Critics: Best Film, Best Director, Best Supporting Actor (Hackman), Best Screenplay.
New York Film Critics Circle: Best Supporting Actor (Hackman).
Named one of the 100 Greatest American Movies by the American Film Institute.

Back to the Top 100.

#11  Fight Club (1999)

Starring Edward Norton, Brad Pitt, Helena Bonham Carter, Meat Loaf, and Jared Leto.
Written by Jim Uhls based on the novel by Chuck Palahniuk.
Directed by David Fincher.

The Grades
Alison
A 
Carlo
A 
Dana
B+
Jeff
A 
Jen
A 
Kris
A 

If there is a film from 1999 that can be described as "visionary," it is Fight Club. It struck a chord with the wired generation (a chord plucked earlier in the year by The Matrix, #15), tangled as we are in the pursuit of money and things we don't really need. Fight Club puts us in the head of its nameless Narrator and takes us on a journey of self-discovery, punctuated with equal parts brutality and hilarity. The greatness of the film lies in its ability to tantalizingly stoke our rage and disillusionment before delivering nihilism to its proper resting place.

Fight Club is a love story and a coming-of-age story, as much as it is an identity crisis, an anti-consumerist rant, a critique of machismo and men's movements, or a satire of cultism. Tyler Durden, the avatar of our Narrator's bifurcated personality, is no match for Marla, his savior. She is the alarm that awakens the Narrator from his somnambulance and self-flagellation. Fight Club downloads its wake-up call into our brains, and dares us to create something new for ourselves.  –Jeff

Read Carlo's full-length review.

Academy Awards™
Nomination: Best Sound Effects Editing.

Other Major Awards
Online Film Critics Society: Nominee for Best Picture, Director, Actor (Norton), Adapted Screenplay, and Film Editing.
AboutFilm.Com's #1 film of 1999.

Back to the Top 100.

#12  Gods and Monsters (1998)

Starring Ian McKellen, Brendan Fraser, and Lynn Redgrave.
Written by Bill Condon based on the novel Father of Frankenstein, by Christopher Bram.
Directed by Bill Condon.

The Grades
Alison
Carlo
Dana
Jeff
Jen
Kris

Gods and Monsters is a small film made great by McKellen's measured portrayal of Frankenstein director James Whale. McKellen eases into the role, drawing out his character's wit in early scenes, bringing his tortured conflicts to the surface later on, and resisting melodrama throughout. Fraser and Redgrave both give outstanding supporting performances, and the film's direction and pacing are effortlessly understated. Performances aside, the film is most memorable for its less conspicuous moments, some of which are a delight. One favorite: a spontaneous photo session involving Whale and his stars from The Bride of Frankenstein, with Boris Karloff's newborn serving as a distraction. "Coochy coo," the former Mrs. Frankenstein utters politely but coolly in the baby's direction.

The humor in these small, ‘present-day' moments (actually the 1950s) balances a series of dramatic flashbacks centered around Whales' involvement in the first World War. While the device allowing for these flashbacks (a stroke that renders Whale unable to control memory flow) may be a bit contrived, the blurring of Whale's past and present is increasingly haunting as the film heads toward its tragic conclusion.  –Kris

Read Carlo's full-length review.

Academy Awards™
Best Adapted Screenplay.
Nominations: Best Actor (McKellen), Best Supporting Actress (Redgrave).

Other Major Awards
British Independent Film Awards: Best Actor (McKellen).
Broadcast Film Critics Association:
Best Actor (McKellen).
Golden Globes: Best Supporting Actress (Redgrave).
Independent Spirit Awards: Best Feature, Best Male Lead (McKellen), Best Supporting Female (Redgrave).
London Critics Circle: British Supporting Actress of the Year.
Los Angeles Film Critics Association: Best Actor (McKellen).
National Board of Review: Best Picture, Best Actor (McKellen).
AboutFilm.Com's #1 film of 1998.

Back to the Top 100.

#13  Hoop Dreams (1994)

Featuring William Gates and Arthur Agee.
Written by Steve James and Frederick Marx.
Directed by Steve James.

The Grades
Alison
A-
Carlo
-
Dana
Jeff
Jen
A-
Kris
-

No fictional sports movie has a story this good. Three hours culled from four years in the lives of two boys in inner-city Chicago, edited masterfully to provide a narrative and thematic drive, Hoop Dreams is the most frank representation of the life and aspirations of the urban poor in America. It is a critique of America, capitalism, the family (particularly fathers), and sports. It examines racism, poverty, drugs, and education. The film compels you to think about the gargantuan struggles some people face that we more privileged do not, which struggles are self-inflicted, and which are engendered by an uncaring, inefficient, and occasionally hostile system. It also makes us aware of the role of chance in our lives–a freak injury or an unpaid school bill can have unforeseen consequences down the road.

Hoop Dreams is not a downer, though. Resilience and faculty overcome heavy obstacles to provide a sense of hope. Dreams may be elusive, but love can keep us afloat.  –Jeff

Academy Awards™
Nominations: Best Film Editing.

Other Major Awards
Directors Guild of America: Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Documentary.
Los Angeles Film Critics Association: Best Documentary.
National Society of Film Critics. Best Documentary.
New York Film Critics Circle: Best Documentary.
Sundance Film Festival: Audience Award.

Back to the Top 100.

#14  Beauty and the Beast (1991)

Starring the voices of Paige O'Hara, Robbie Benson, Richard White, Jerry Orbach, David Ogden Stiers, and Angela Lansbury.
Written by Linda Woolverton and Roger Allers.
Directed by Gary Trousdale and Kirk Wise.

The Grades
Alison
B+
Carlo
A-
Dana
A-
Jeff
Jen
A+
Kris
-

Beauty and the Beast is by far the best of Disney's most recent animated features. It balances cute, cartoony humor with a well-written story so well that children and adults will find it equally satisfying. Belle is a heroine ahead of her time. The brown-eyed, brunette beauty is an avid reader with dreams of a bigger, more adventurous life than her provincial town can offer. Little does she know that her dreams are about to come true.

The Beast (he is never mentioned by name) is the quintessential romantic hero. Even in his monstrous form, he's magnetically attractive. A sensitive, tortured brute, he appeals to those of us who long to heal another soul with the power of our love. He meets Belle with his hair bristling and with an awesome, roaring voice (which I still can't believe came out of Robbie Benson), and slowly becomes an insecure, needy sweetheart.

We all know, intellectually, that we don't have the power to change any other individual but ourselves. But in our hearts, and in our fantasies, we yearn to make a difference, to forever alter our beloved's life. By just being herself, Belle literally transforms the Beast, and I don't know anybody who wouldn't find that romantic.  –Jen

Academy Awards™
Best Original Score, Best Song ("Beauty and the Beast").
Nominations: Best Picture, Best Song ("Be Our Guest"), Best Song ("Belle"), Best Sound.

Other Major Awards
Golden Globes: Best Picture-Comedy/Musical, Best Score, Best Song ("Beauty and the Beast").
Los Angeles Film Critics Association: Best Animation
National Board of Review: Special Award for Animation.

Back to the Top 100.

#15  The Matrix (1999)

Starring Keanu Reeves, Laurence Fishburne, Carrie-Anne Moss, Hugo Weaving, and Joe Pantoliano.
Written by Andy and Larry Wachowski.
Directed by Andy and Larry Wachowski.

The Grades
Alison
A 
Carlo
Dana
A-
Jeff
B+
Jen
A 
Kris
A-

The Matrix is a perfect encapsulation of fin-de-siécle zeitgeist at the doorstep of our new millennium. Blending comix/animé visuals, balletic kung-fu acrobatics, cyberpunk paranoia laced with pop culture references of days gone by, and mind-bending special effects that may soon render it passé, The Matrix captures our communal thoughtscape circa the late 20th century. Fittingly, that's what The Matrix is about–the collective dreamworld we inhabit and who has dominion over it.

Kicking off the theme that would be further explored in other, more "serious" films of 1999, such as Fight Club (#11) and American Beauty (#21), The Matrix exhorts us to take control of our lives. With its superhero parable of The One, it addresses the level to which we've allowed machines to remove us from that which is real. The Matrix reminds us that we are "the ones" with the power over our lives; all we have to do is exercise it.

Oh, yeah... It also kicks serious ass.  –Alison

Read Carlo's full-length review and analysis.

Academy Awards™
Best Film Editing, Best Visual Effects, Best Sound, Best Sound Effects Editing.

Other Major Awards
American Cinema Editors: Best Edited Feature Film.
British Academy Awards: Awards pending. Nominated for Best Cinematography, Best Editing, Best Production Design, Best Achievement in Special Visual Effects, Best Sound.

Back to the Top 100.

#16  Fargo (1996)

Starring Frances McDormand, William H. Macy, Steve Buscemi, Peter Stormare, and Harve Presnell.
Written by Joel and Ethan Coen.
Directed by Joel Coen.

The Grades
Alison
Carlo
B+
Dana
Jeff
Jen
Kris
B+

Fargo is not–as its opening title states–based on a true story, but that doesn't mean it's not about the truth. Tapping directly into the infinite wellspring of human folly, the Coen Brothers find both humor and pathos in this tale of one man's desperate attempt to cloak his mistakes and failures by arranging a "harmless" kidnapping of his wife. His blunders and miscalculations are compounded by those of the thugs he hires, creating a snowball effect that results in a slew of unintended carnage.

Though its tone is often lightened and enriched by the Coen's affection for mundane detail and local color, Fargo is as suspenseful and as thematically bleak as its stunningly atmospheric cinematography and score.  The film's ray of hope is embodied in Marge Gunderson (McDormand), one of modern cinema's most awesomely crafted characters. Fargo is often chided for mocking the midwesterners who populate its story, but Marge puts the lie to that criticism. She's a true rarity: a character who demonstrates that simplicity is not stupidity, decency is not naiveté, and that sophistication is not a prerequisite for wisdom.

Equal parts dark humor and sincere lament, Fargo tells the truth about the blinding qualities of fear and greed, and about the absurdly predictable frailty and ineptitude of human beings. Yet somehow, it manages to conclude on a sublimely life-affirming note. Conjuring a universe that is at once singular and familiar, Fargo is that rarest of breeds: a film that genuinely merits the word unique. It is, quite simply, superb.  –Dana

Academy Awards™
Best Actress (McDormand), Best Original Screenplay.
Nominations: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Supporting Actor (Macy), Best Cinematography, Best Film Editing.

Other Major Awards
British Academy Awards: Best Director.
Broadcast Film Critics Association: Best Picture, Best Actress (McDormand).
Cannes Film Festival: Best Director.
Independent Spirit Awards: Best Feature, Best Director, Best Female Lead (McDormand), Best Male Lead (Macy), Best Screenplay, Best Cinematographer.
London Critics Circle: Film of the Year, Director of the Year, Actress of the Year (McDormand), Screenwriters of the Year.
Los Angeles Film Critics Association: Best Screenplay.
National Board of Review: Best Director, Best Actress (McDormand).
New York Film Critics Circle: Best Film.
Screen Actors Guild: Outstanding Performance by a Female Lead Actor (McDormand).
Writers Guild of America: Best Original Screenplay.

Named one of the 100 Greatest American Movies by the American Film Institute.

  Comment on this feature
  Read user comments
  Previous page (numbers 1-8)

  Next page (numbers 17-25)
  Features Index